
Cordillera Escalera
SUMMARY AND CAUSES OF CONFLICT
Tensions between the Cordillera Escalera conservation area (ACR-CE) and the indigenous Kichwa communities which live around the outskirts have been high since the creation of the area in 2005. This is because these communities have ancestrally used territories which were legally fenced off to them by the creation of the ACR-CE. Suddenly, when they went to hunt or forage in their ancestral lands, they encountered park rangers who told them that this land belonged to the regional government, that hunting was illegal here and that they had to leave. Communities were confused and felt as if the management of the ACR-CE had disregarded their right to their lands.
The management of the ACR-CE, on the other hand, has their own view of the events. When the conservation area was being formed an important national law called “Free, Prior and Informed Consent” (Ley del Derecho a La Consulta Previa a Los Pueblos Indígenas U Originarios, Ley N.° 29785, 2011) was not yet created. This law requires that all titled communities are consulted before any development or land use change occurs. Even still, the organization in charge of the justification study that underpinned the area's creation, the local NGO CEDISA, conducted workshops with communities in order to obtain their consent and support.
Communities say that either the workshops were not comprehensive and they did not understand what having a conservation area would mean for them, or that these workshops never happened at all. Conflicting perspectives and experiences of events are at the heart of the disagreements between the ACR-CE and native communities organized in federations. To better understand the pathways to agreements that may exist, we present here the many perspectives of some of the actors involved.
These contrasting accounts reveal that the conflict is not only about access to land and natural resources, but also about recognition of ancestral territorial rights, participation in decision-making, legal legitimacy, and trust between institutions and Indigenous communities. Understanding these overlapping dimensions is essential for identifying pathways toward more just, inclusive, and lasting agreements.
The School for Field Studies is a United States environmental study abroad program provider for undergraduate college students. offering semester- and summer-long academic programs in 12 countries around the world. SFS works in collaboration with local partners to study and address environmental issues which affect local communities and ecosystems.
In Peru, SFS is based in Tarapoto, San Martín, where Political Ecology staff and students have been exploring the conflict between Kichwa communities and the Área de Conservación Regional Cordillera Escalera (ACR-CE).
The above documentary was produced by the Spring 2025 SFS cohort, and continues to highlight the themes of conflict surrounding Cordillera Escalera.
ACR-CE Conflict Analysis by SFS
So far, both prior Directed Research projects have highlighted the Kichwa community’s dilemmas and strategies in navigating conservation frameworks, while seeking to maintain autonomy and control over their ancestral lands. It was also recognized that the conflict has reached a deadlock that will not be resolved if the different parties continue to remain trapped in their own narratives and focus only on the most tangible issues (such as land titling or restrictions on land use). While these are important matters, if the actors address the conflict only from the visible tip of the iceberg, without exploring the underlying fears, hopes, and interests, it will be difficult to achieve a real transformation of the conflict.
Based on this insight, during May/April 2026, SFS research aimed to move beyond narrative analysis toward analyzing the root causes of the conflict. The research explored attitudes, behaviors, and underlying contradictions of actors that shape and sustain conflict, and results in forms of structural and cultural violence and environmental injustice. This website is one of the culminating products of our investigation.

Individual Actors Interviewed

Attorney at the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL)
Cristina Gavancho

Former Director (Jefe) of the Área de Conservación Regional Cordillera Escalera
Mario Ríos Vela

Current Director (Jefe) of the Área de Conservación Regional Cordillera Escalera
César Alfonso Bardalez Pizarro

President of the Federation of Kichwa Indigenous Peoples of Chazuta Amazonas (FEPIKECHA)
Hilter Macedo Tuanama

Apu of the Native Community of Rebalse de Chazuta (left), Former President of the Women's Association - Shunku Warmikuna (right)
Milly Chujutalli Zumba (left), Luz Hidrogo Terrones (right)

Former President of the Federation of Kichwa Indigenous Peoples of Chazuta Amazonas (FEPIKECHA) and Former board member of the Coordinator for the Development and Defence of Indigenous Peoples of the San Martin Region (CODEPISAM)
Marisol García Apagueño

Program Coordinator for Rights, Gender, and Citizenship at CEDISA
Martha Del Castillo Morey
Personal Statements

Looking Ahead
Looking towards the future, we want to find resolutions to this conflict that take into account the needs of all actors present.
Many actors express openness for dialogue, but even so, the conflict has reached a deadlock that will be difficult to solve without a constructive dialogue, exploring the underlying attitudes, beliefs, fears and hope.
Through our interviews, we were presented with many possible solutions, but it’s important to analyze how realistic these solutions are.
Co-management
Co-management was one idea discussed by various actors. Co-management needs to be based on inclusive decision-making processes, respecting legislation regarding Free, Prior, and Informed Consent, Indigenous participation in management, the ability to participate in financial benefits from conservation activities, and the ability to use the resources in the area without restrictions. It also implies that ACR-CE management should facilitate, within the framework of their competences, the implementation of communal titling processes.
The issue is that many communities and NGOs would like to have co-management, but when talking with different actors, it was apparent that there are discrepancies when it comes to the actual meaning of co-management. Actors would need to engage in a constructive dialogue to define the meaning and ways of implementation of co-management. Some actors claim that legislation at the National level would also need to change to allow for co-management based on titling of ancestral territories, which will likely not happen soon, but is the long-term goal for many communities. Others are open to explore co-management options based on a right-of-use arrangement (user concession, see below).
User Concessions (as a step towards land ownership)
User Concessions were discussed by many communities and former directors of the ACR-CE. Within protected conservation areas, the government cannot give away or sell spaces. Even though the Ministerial Resolution N.º 0136 (2022-MIDAGRI) allows Indigenous ancestral territory to be demarcated even if it overlaps with protected areas or classified lands, full titling is a legal impossibility. Currently, the only thing that would be possible is a user concession. This is a binding contract between the regional government and a community that grants specific rights to use the land and resources within the ACR-CE. Ultimately, most communities want titles over their full ancestral territory, but being granted a user concession is a step in the right direction. A user concession would be the first legal position to have and use this to keep pressuring for a title.
One community that we spoke with explained how they would not be satisfied with this method because it is not guaranteed and the government can take it back at any point. It also implies still being subject to control from the regional government, on the basis of a management plan.
Ecotourism
Ecotourism is presented by some actors as an alternative livelihood option for communities, that allows them to protect the land while at the same time obtaining financial benefits. This normally goes hand-in-hand with a user concession, where communities can financially benefit from using the land without owning it. For example, associations within the ACR-CE, such as Alto Shilcayo or Ahuashiyacu, promote ecotourism based on natural attractions like waterfalls. Ecotourism strategies generate revenue from tourists wanting to visit, based on a user concession over a specific area. The associations charge 10 soles as an entrance fee while managing the area locally. This is not a large amount, but it helps a little.
Others doubt the feasibility of this strategy. Beyond the lack of autonomy associated with not holding ownership rights, such revenues are unlikely to generate sufficient financial resources to offset the land-use restrictions imposed on the wider community. At the same time, this option is impossible for communities without natural resources to commodify, nor does it guarantee the continuity and reproduction of local cultural practices and ways of life.
Open Dialogue
The least arguable solution is a more open dialogue between actors. This is a desire in almost every location we visited. The director of the ACR-CE admits that he mainly interacts with communities through federations, but he would like to work with people directly. Another association says that they want to be able to report to authorities. Dialogue should include agreements to improve that situation, and they are open to that. The communities aren't against conservation; it's something they have been doing for a very long time, but they also want there to be more opportunities for themselves and their families. This conflict has been very polarizing, but the truth is that both views want conservation. They do not need to be against each other, rather working together to create solutions that can benefit everyone involved.
